The Influence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Transforming Marketing Communications: A Theoretical Review

KeywordsArtificial intelligence customer experience enhancement digital transformation ethical and privacy concerns marketing communications

JEL Classification M31

Full Article

1. Introduction

With the surge in computing power, more affordable computing costs, and the availability of big data, the significance of AI in marketing has grown. Its broad applications are evident across various marketing domains (Huang and Rust, 2020). This research aimed to investigate and comprehend the pivotal aspects of marketing communications transformed by AI. In the rapidly changing landscape of AI's integration into marketing communications, there exists a pressing need to understand the frameworks developed for AI. This urgency arises from the escalating complexity of AI applications, the rapid pace of technological advancements, and the growing reliance of marketing strategies on AI-driven tools. As businesses strive to harness the full potential of AI in enhancing their marketing communications, an understanding of these frameworks becomes imperative. This study delved into these frameworks, critically examining their design, practical application, and the far-reaching implications they hold for the field of marketing communications.

Girdhar (2023) observed that fuelled by data from digital channels and intricate consumer behaviour dynamics, marketers are increasingly turning to Artificial Intelligence for insights and automation. AI's prowess in data handling, as emphasised by Girdhar (2023), paves the way for revolutionising marketing techniques. However, alongside its merits, AI introduces ethical dilemmas, including privacy concerns and potential employment shifts. Thus, this research also focused on the challenges posed by AI in marketing communications.

The escalating computing capabilities and the omnipresence of big data have propelled the role of AI in marketing, as highlighted by Huang and Rust (2020). This surge in technological prowess has not only transformed business operations, as observed by Pascucci et al. (2023), but has also given rise to new opportunities for marketers through the integration of the internet, social media, and mobile devices. As Ekström (2023) underscores, this digital evolution enables marketers to leverage vast datasets for crafting tailored campaigns. In the ever-evolving landscape shaped by these technological shifts, the profound impact of AI on marketing communications becomes increasingly apparent. Acknowledged for its significance by experts such as Girdhar (2023) and Longoni et al. (2019), AI presents a transformative force in the field of marketing communications. Despite these acknowledgments, a comprehensive understanding of how AI precisely shapes marketing communications remains elusive.

The aim of this research was to explore frameworks of AI integration into marketing communications and critically examine their design, practical application and implications. The urgency of this investigation was underscored by the rapid pace of technological advancements, the growing reliance on AI-driven tools, and the escalating complexity of AI applications. This research aligned with the imperative outlined by Girdhar (2023) regarding the increasing dependence of marketers on AI for insights and automation and aimed to identify, explore, and establish the reshaping, trends, and limitations of AI in marketing communications. In doing so, this research contributes not only to academic knowledge but also provides practical insights for businesses navigating the intricate intersection of AI and marketing communications.

2. Literature Review

2.1 Artificial Intelligence Marketing (AIM)

Artificial Intelligence Marketing (AIM) harnesses artificial intelligence to automate the assimilation and organisation of vast data sets related to the marketing mix and a multitude of marketing functions in a market intelligence generation (Verma et al., 2021). Overgoor et al. (2019, p.157) describe artificial intelligence marketing as agents founded on artificial intelligence (AI) principles, which leverage data for optimal marketing outcomes on a global scale. Artificial intelligence is the most recent technological disruptor and has enormous marketing transformation potential. Marketing practitioners globally seek to identify AI solutions that best align with their contemporary marketing needs. This trend transcends regional boundaries and is universally experienced. Consequently, cutting-edge technologies, such as AI, have moved beyond the experimental stage and are seamlessly integrated into core business operations, positioning enterprises at the forefront of success (Chintalapati and Pandey, 2021).

Artificial intelligence shapes every element of the marketing mix. In product design and development, AI creates bespoke products by sifting through vast volumes of customer feedback and market data (Chatterjee et al., 2019). When it comes to pricing, businesses across the world harness artificial intelligence’s prowess for dynamic pricing, synthesising diverse data to strike a balance between competitiveness and profitability (Vollero and Palazzo, 2015). In distribution, or 'place', artificial intelligence’s fingerprints are evident in optimised supply chain operations, predicting consumer demand patterns and elevating the delivery experience (Liao, 2014). The domain of promotion also witnessed a paradigm shift with artificial intelligence at the helm, facilitating tailor-made campaigns that target consumers aptly in our hyper-connected world (Misra et al., 2019). Furthermore, artificial intelligence’s role in customer engagement through chatbots and virtual assistants prompts contemplation on the current AI-driven trends in marketing (Gans, 2016; Huang and Rust, 2018).

Roetzer (2017), CEO of the Marketing Artificial Intelligence Institute, posits that in an era where artificial intelligence persistently redraws boundaries, the classic 4Ps are undergoing evolution. Roetzer (2017) introduces a transformative fifth 'P' – performance. This addition provides a panoramic view of the artificial intelligence (AI) - integrated marketing landscape, where the ambit extends beyond just the initial 4Ps to encompass planning, production, personalisation, promotion, and performance. This perspective illustrates a global marketing framework that is growing ever more dependent on artificial intelligence (AI), from its role in strategising to leveraging vast data for actionable insights. The framework presented by Roetzer (2017) is not merely theoretical; it signifies a tangible, AI-led metamorphosis in global marketing. It challenges industry stakeholders to introspect the pervasive influence of AI on contemporary marketing practices, highlighting AI’s pivotal role in driving the industry towards elevated levels of automation and intelligence.

2.2 AI Dimensions: Mechanical, Thinking, and Feeling

The assimilation of AI into the mix necessitates a recalibrated strategic approach. Huang and Rust's (2020) innovative framework encapsulates this transformation, spotlighting the trinity of artificial intelligence facets: mechanical artificial intelligence, thinking artificial intelligence and feeling artificial intelligence. Mechanical AI, due to the ability to achieve consistency, is linked to the standardisation benefits and reliable outcomes. In marketing, some examples are the use of self-service robots and drones used for the distribution of goods. Thinking AI is linked to personalisation benefits which is due to the ability to understand and recognise data patterns (such as, facial recognition, speech recognition). In marketing, thinking AI can be used across various personalised recommendation systems (Chung et al., 2015) such as Netflix series and Amazon cross-selling recommendations. Feeling AI is linked to relationalisation benefits due to the ability to not only recognise emotions, but also respond to emotions. In marketing, the biggest benefit would be on customer service, that is, dealing with customer complaints, satisfaction and emotions.

Overlaying these artificial intelligence dimensions into time-honoured marketing principles, a change in the basic assumptions of segmentation, targeting, and positioning (STP), to the venerable 4Ps (product, price, place, and promotion) and their 4Cs (customer, cost, convenience, and communication) counterparts, reveal a paradigm shift. Laying the foundational stone of this framework AI's seamless amalgamation with marketing research emerges as a game-changer (Huang and Rust, 2020). The mechanical (AI), with its unmatched prowess, taps into a torrent of real-time data from emerging global channels: the Internet of Things (IoT), wearables, and social media platforms. Yet, this autonomous efficiency raises ethical dilemmas, and the need to contemplate the challenges artificial intelligence might pose in terms of ethics and data privacy (Balducci and Marinova, 2018).

2.2.1 Transformative Shifts in Segmentation, Targeting, and Positioning

Venturing into the strategic sphere of segmentation, targeting, and positioning (STP), thinking (AI), as highlighted by Huang andRust (2020), spearheads transformative shifts. It propels segmentation beyond the orthodox, wielding data mining to unearth market intricacies that span continents. Such depth arms global marketers with precise consumer targeting, refining outreach as insights become increasingly tailored. However, as Kelly (2019) notes, while AI reshapes segmentation and targeting, authentic positioning still hinges on the timeless essence of human emotion. As this study explored marketing communication, the examination of artificial intelligence's dynamic interaction with the foundational 4Ps (product, price, place, and promotion) and their 4Cs counterparts served as a critical focal point. The collaboration between AI and these marketing pillars forms the crux of this investigation and aims to understand the transformative implications for contemporary marketing practices.

2.2.2 Collaborative Interaction with the 4Ps and 4Cs

By drawing attention to the cognitive abilities of AI in uncovering latent consumer needs, the research aligns with the inherent role of AI in shaping products in harmony with genuine market demands. The discussion on the transformation of pricing structures under the guidance of AI directly links to this paper’s focus on understanding the reshaping of traditional marketing paradigms. This alignment reinforces the contextual relevance of this research, showcasing the practical implications of AI in pricing strategies within the global marketing landscape. Moreover, the consideration of potential gaps in the distribution spectrum, despite the enriching role of mechanical (AI), ties directly to this paper’s exploration of the risks and challenges posed by AI in marketing. This alignment underscores the need to critically assess the impact of AI on the global relationship between brands and consumers, a key facet of this paper’s focus.

In highlighting the influence of AI in media planning and content creation, as brought forth by Huang and Rust (2020), the paper emphasises the contemporary significance of AI in reshaping marketing communications practices. The paper also positions the triad of artificial intelligence, as articulated by Huang and Rust (2020), as a guiding beacon for marketers worldwide, aligning precisely with the overarching aim to understand and navigate the transformative role of AI in the realm of marketing communications on a global scale.

2.3 Reshaping Products, Pricing, and Distribution

Artificial intelligence reshapes the very essence of the marketing mix. It empowers enterprises, irrespective of geographical boundaries, to base their decisions on concrete data, refine their operational processes, and curate bespoke experiences for consumers. Spanning from product ideation to pricing mechanisms, distribution logistics, and promotional campaigns, AI technologies are ushering in a new era of marketing strategy formulation. By adeptly leveraging artificial intelligence, businesses are not only positioning themselves at the vanguard of their respective industries but are also amplifying customer engagement and propelling growth in the increasingly digital global marketplace (Maxwell et al., 2011).

With artificial intelligence’s multi-tiered intelligence spectrum—spanning mechanical, thinking, and feeling—its trajectory transitions from handling basic mechanised tasks to sophisticated endeavours, such as interpreting sentiments on global social media platforms. In this dynamic evolution, AI not only challenges traditional boundaries but also reshapes the landscape of global marketing communications strategies, emphasising a harmonious merger of artificial intelligence and human intelligence (HI). However, this ascension of artificial intelligence does not relegate human contributions to the backseat. Raisch and Krakowski (2021, p.194), spotlight the "automation-augmentation paradox" which highlights the ebb and flow between artificial intelligence’s potential to take on human roles and scenarios where humans work alongside machines in tandem.

Drawing from Huang and Rust (2020), the trajectory of technology over time often follows a pattern: it begins by augmenting human capabilities and, as it matures, gravitates towards full automation. This narrative can be traced from the era of the industrial revolution to current discussions surrounding autonomous vehicles. Huang and Rust (2020) posit a model where AI and HI coexist not as adversaries but as collaborative entities. In the context of this research, on the evolving landscape of artificial intelligence in marketing communications, their perspective becomes particularly relevant. They foresee a future where AI, as it progresses along its intelligence continuum, initially augments, and may eventually replace certain facets of human intelligence. Central to their argument is the proposition that AI and HI should be perceived, not as competitors but as interdependent pillars, collaboratively shaping our integrated, digital global marketplace. This collaborative framework laid out by Huang and Rust (2020) serves as a foundational concept for understanding the intricate relationship between AI and HI in the context of marketing communications strategies.

2.4 Artificial Intelligence Marketing (AIM) Framework

Yau et al (2021) propose an artificial intelligence marketing (AIM) framework, from an interdisciplinary perspective, that focuses on the use of artificial intelligence to not only create knowledge, but also distribute and apply said knowledge with the purpose of enhancing customer relationships in a knowledge-based context. This approach is of critical importance due to its ability to harness AI's prowess in automating the intricate nexus of data collection and analysis within the marketing spectrum. The framework comprises three foundational pillars: the pre-processor, main processor, and memory storage. The pre-processor acts as the gateway, assimilating and pre-emptively sifting through vast troves of data, priming them for intricate scrutiny. The main processor, identified as the heart of this framework by Yau et al (2021) boasts versatile cognitive capacities, straddling various learning modalities. It orchestrates real-time data operations, assimilates reinforcement learning, and orchestrates marketing tactics. Its interactions span the spectrum, from complete AI-driven autonomy to myriad forms of human- artificial intelligence synergy. The memory storage serves as a reservoir for curating and cataloguing data, insights, and information.

The significance of the AIM framework becomes evident as it not only streamlines and enhances marketing processes but also addresses the escalating complexities of handling vast amounts of data in the contemporary marketing landscape. This, in turn, positions AIM as a pivotal tool for marketers seeking to navigate and capitalise on the evolving dynamics of the digital age. Yau et al’s (2021) AIM framework not only mirrors real-time shifts in consumer trends and behaviours but also ensures that marketing initiatives remain agile and effective. They emphasise that the AIM framework operates at the forefront of a data-centric, scalable, and deeply personalised marketing strategy.

3. Research Methodology

The research followed a qualitative research design, and delved into understanding and interpreting social phenomena from the perspectives and experiences of individuals involved, utilising non-numerical data such as interviews, observations, and textual materials to unveil underlying meanings, patterns, and themes (Creswell and Creswell, 2018). Secondary data was used to write this paper, specifically a descriptive literature review approach. This approach was used to collect and evaluate published works in the field of AI marketing which allowed for an in-depth exploration and interpretation of existing knowledge, ensuring a detailed analysis of the transformative role played by AI in marketing communications. Published works covered various themes such as strategic frameworks, AI's impact on marketing mix, pitfalls, opportunities, and the influence of AI on consumer behaviour in digital marketing were collected and analysed. Purposive sampling, also known as judgemental, selective, or subjective sampling Robson (2016) was used in this study because it allowed for a specific focus on sources and studies that were most relevant to the topic of AI in marketing communications. After reviewing the initial collection of data, a final selection of articles (n=25) were then analysed.

Thematic analysis, used to analyse the data, is a qualitative research method that can be widely used across a range of epistemologies and research questions. It is a method for identifying, analysing, organising, describing, and reporting themes found within a data set (Braun and Clarke, 2006). To ensure the credibility of the data collection and analysis, the concept of authenticity (Mogalakwe, 2006) was employed. Authenticity pertains to the genuineness of evidence and its origin. This foundational criterion ensured that the documents being analysed were genuine, intact, and indeed represents what it claims to. Factors that may necessitate scrutiny of a document include obvious errors, internal inconsistencies, or when the version available emerges from a dubious source (Mogalakwe, 2006). Regarding trustworthiness, one of its core elements is credibility, which pertains to whether the evidence is free from error and distortion (Mogalakwe, 2006). In the context of this study, it was imperative to discern whether the sourced documents were sincere, unaltered, and not produced to mislead the researcher. This aspect was particularly significant when dealing with reports, documents, or articles that may have vested interests or biases. The credibility of the documents and their alignment with the study's goals was crucial in ensuring the results drawn from the research were both accurate and representative. Following a thematic analysis of the published works, key themes and sub-themes were identified. Table 1 outlines the finalisation of the themes and sub-themes in relation to the study’s research questions.

Table 1: Themes Aligned to Research Questions

4. Discussion of Themes

Under Theme 1, "Strategic Digital Transformation," the focus is on the overarching impact of AI, with sub-themes delving into strategic decision-making and the evolution of digital marketing strategies. Theme 2, "Customer Experience Enhancement," explores the transformative influence of AI on contemporary marketing practices, emphasising the sub-themes of personalisation and automation. Theme 3 underscores the critical considerations of "Ethical and Privacy Concerns," unravelling sub-themes related to ethical issues, bias mitigation, and the imperative of ensuring privacy and security.

4.1 Strategic Digital Transformation

The transformative influence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) on marketing communications is evident in its impact on strategic digital transformation. This theme delves into two interconnected sub-themes: Strategies and Strategic Decision-Making, and Digital Marketing, exploring the fundamental changes AI introduces to the pillars of modern marketing communications practices. The sub-theme Strategies and Strategic Decision-Making explores the pivotal domain of strategies and strategic decision-making within the dynamic landscape of marketing communications shaped by AI. Four key areas are highlighted, namely (i) recalibration of approaches, (ii) data-driven decision-making, (iii) integral role of AI and (iv) creative analytics.

• Recalibration of approaches: In the context of AI's impact, strategies and strategic decision-making signify the recalibration of approaches and decision processes adopted by marketing practitioners. The infusion of AI technologies introduces novel tools and methodologies, necessitating a fundamental re-evaluation of traditional strategies.
• Data-Driven decision-making: This emphasises the profound changes AI brings to strategic decision-making in marketing. Haenlein and Kaplan (2019) highlight that AI augments decision-making by providing data-driven insights, enabling informed and precise strategic choices. Wright et al. (2020) extend this perspective, showcasing AI's role in operational markets for risk identification, consumer research, and aligning business functions with target customers.
• Integral role of AI: Insights from Martínez-López and Casillas (2013) underscore AI's increasing importance in strategic marketing decision management. The study aligns with the research question, demonstrating AI's integral role in formulating marketing communications strategies. The presence of AI in strategic decision management is validated by contrasting views on its tactical use and its role in making strategic decisions, highlighting how AI actively influences marketing communications strategies.
• Creative analytics: The concept of "Creative Analytics" proposed by Eriksson et al. (2020) extends AI's role beyond rational processes to impact creative aspects in marketing strategy formulation. Chintalapati and Pandey (2021) highlight that adapting AI-enabled marketing practices improves innovation in marketing strategies and campaigns across all functional areas of marketing.
• The sub-theme Digital Marketing explores the transformative influence of AI on digital marketing within the dynamic landscape of marketing communications. Five key areas are highlighted, namely: (i) foundational research; (ii) paradigm shift in client experiences, (iii) AI-driven digital marketing strategies; (iv) impact factors and (v) shaping the future.
• Foundational Research: Digital marketing, profoundly impacted by the AI revolution, has been scrutinised by researchers such as Murgai (2018), Khokhar and Chitsimran (2019), and Krsteva (2016). This foundational research sets the stage for understanding the depth of AI's influence on digital marketing practices, emphasising the need for in-depth exploration into the opportunities and challenges presented by this integration (Chintalapati and Pandey, 2021).
• Paradigm Shift in Client Experiences: The integration of AI into digital marketing strategies marks a paradigm shift in client experiences across platforms, especially on social media giants like Facebook and Instagram. Platforms leverage AI to analyse user information meticulously, tailoring offers to align with individual preferences and needs.
• AI-Driven Digital Marketing Strategies: Building upon the transformative impact outlined in the first sub-theme; the sub-theme Digital Marketing focuses on AI-driven digital marketing strategies. Haleem et al. (2022) emphasise the efficiency and accuracy of AI-driven digital marketing and data analysis strategies, surpassing human capabilities. AI's concentration on user retention and lead conversion is evident through intuitive AI chatbots, intelligent email marketing, interactive web design, and various digital marketing services.
• Factors Determining Impact: This facet of the study explores the factors determining the impact of AI on digital marketing. Forrest and Hoanca (2015) and Dumitriu and Popescu (2020) highlight AI's efficiency in determining customer-centric content and its ability to process vast data points on the internet exemplify its impact on digital marketing, allowing marketers to target the right audience promptly and effectively.
• Shaping the Future: The integration of AI in marketing, coupled with marketing automation, translates data into meaningful interactions, influencing favourable business outcomes. AI's influence extends to shaping the future of digital marketing, leveraging the Internet of Things (IoT), and connected devices, this emphasises the imperative for marketers to adapt to the transformative potential of AI in the ever evolving and dynamic digital marketing communications ecosystem.

The examination of strategies and strategic decision-making as well as digital marketing within the context of AI's influence underscores the profound impact on marketing communications. The recalibration of traditional approaches, the introduction of data-driven decision-making, and the paradigm shift in client experiences highlight AI's transformative potential. As AI-driven digital marketing strategies become increasingly efficient and accurate, marketers must adapt to the evolving landscape, leveraging AI's capabilities for enhanced customer engagement, predicting consumer behaviour, and automating strategic marketing decisions. This theme emphasises the imperative for marketers to not only recognise but actively embrace the transformative potential of AI in shaping the future of marketing communications.

4.2 Customer Experience Enhancement

Theme 2, Customer Experience Enhancement, focuses on understanding how Artificial Intelligence has influenced contemporary marketing trends and practices. This theme focuses on two pivotal sub-themes, namely Personalisation and Automation, aiming to uncover the impact of AI on reshaping the dynamics of marketing communications. Research Question 2 directs the exploration: How has the introduction of Artificial Intelligence influenced contemporary marketing trends and practices? The sub-theme personalisation focuses on how Artificial Intelligence (AI) influences contemporary marketing trends and practices by exploring the areas of digital experiences, content surge, AI-powered chatbots and virtual assistants, advanced algorithms and predictive analytics, convergence of personalisation and AI and AI's future role.

• Enriching Digital Experiences: AI is identified as a key player in enriching digital experiences by delivering personalised content, contributing to the future of digital marketing based on trust-building and individualised consumer interactions (Rabby et al., 2021).
• Addressing Content Surge: With the exponential growth of content across various media, the demand for extreme personalisation has increased. AI-powered content recommender systems respond to this need by employing narrative science methodologies (Karimova and Shirkhanbeik, 2019; Kose et al., 2017).
• Impact of AI-Powered Chatbots and Virtual Assistants: AI-powered chatbots and virtual assistants have a revolutionary impact on customer service, offering personalised and instant support. Additionally, AI-driven recommendation systems significantly enhance customer experiences by providing personalised product suggestions and tailored content (Girdhar, 2023).
• Advanced Algorithms and Predictive Analytics: AI empowers marketers to deliver highly personalised content and experiences through advanced algorithms that analyse customer data, predict preferences, and tailor messages. This not only amplifies engagement but also influences conversion rates (Nolden, 2023).
• Convergence of Personalisation and AI: The study by Kumar et al. (2019) explores the convergence of personalisation and AI, distinguishing between firm-controlled personalisation using customer data and customer-decided customisation. Examples like the "recommended for you" section in platforms like Amazon illustrate diverse ways personalisation operates.
• AI's Popularity and Future Role: AI's popularity in personalisation stems from its deep-learning, data-driven approach. The success of personalisation initiatives in an AI-driven environment depends on the volume and quality of customer information, the ability to generate insights, and effective implementation. Kumar et al. (2019) predict that AI will continue to play a transformative role in personalisation, creating superior brand experiences and fostering brand trust.

Automation, within the broader realm of AI, plays a pivotal role in reshaping marketing practices. It involves the use of AI algorithms and technologies to automate routine tasks, interpret customer intents, and optimise service processes. The exploration of the sub-theme Automation in Customer Interactions seeks to understand the influence of AI on modern marketing.

• Continuous Learning and Interpretation of Buying Intents: Chintalapati and Pandey (2021) highlight AI's capacity to continuously learn and interpret customer buying intents, leading to unprecedented levels of automation and personalisation.
• Role of AI-Assisted Service Process Automation: AI-assisted service process automation, as presented by Huang and Rust (2018), extends beyond efficiency gains, providing opportunities for enhanced performance and productivity.
• Intersection of AI, Automation, and Continuous Learning: AI operates at the intersection of automation and continuous learning, driving data-focused analytics and decision-making processes. Technologies like deep learning, genetic algorithms, and natural language processing contribute to automating activities involved in collecting, storing, managing, and retrieving information (Kumar et al., 2019).
• Marketing Automation: Siddiqui and Malviya (2022) elaborate on marketing automation, emphasising its role in automating essential company needs, including email newsletters and social media post scheduling.
• Augmented vs. Automated AI: The distinction between augmented and automated AI is introduced, highlighting the consensus that AI should augment rather than automate, underlining the importance of human involvement in decisions involving any margin of error (Siddiqui and Malviya, 2022).

The exploration of sub-themes personalisation and automation emphasise the influence of AI on reshaping marketing communications. AI serves as the cornerstone for personalisation, influencing present practices and paving the way for an AI-driven future where businesses leverage its capabilities for unparalleled customer engagement and brand loyalty. Additionally, automation emerges as a critical facet in the AI-driven transformation of marketing communications, showcasing dynamic and multifaceted roles from automating routine tasks to influencing decision-making processes. These insights align with the overarching research question, providing a holistic understanding of how AI reshapes the marketing communications landscape.

4.3 Ethical and Privacy Concerns

The infusion of Artificial Intelligence into marketing communications has ushered in transformative capabilities, empowering businesses to understand consumer behaviours, automate processes, and optimise efficiency. However, this technological progression introduces a host of ethical and privacy concerns that warrant meticulous exploration. This analysis, aligned with Research Question 3—focusing on the potential pitfalls and challenges posed by AI in marketing communications—delves into two vital sub-themes: Ethical Issues and Bias, and Privacy and Security.

In the dynamic landscape of marketing communications, the infusion of Artificial Intelligence introduces a complex interplay of technological capabilities and ethical considerations. Understanding the ethical dimensions is paramount as organisations deploy AI-driven tools to shape consumer experiences. The sub-theme Ethical Considerations scrutinises the ethical concerns associated with AI in marketing and sheds light on the implications for businesses and consumers alike.

• Consumer Trust and Transparency: The cornerstone of AI-driven marketing ethics lies in fostering and maintaining consumer trust. As AI algorithms analyse vast datasets to inform personalised marketing strategies, transparency in data usage becomes imperative. Consumers, rightfully, seek to comprehend how their data is utilised, necessitating clear communication from marketers. The work of Martin and Murphy (2016) emphasise the ethical importance of organisational transparency, aligning with consumer expectations and legal mandates.
• Algorithmic Bias and Fairness: The omnipresence of algorithms in AI introduces the risk of bias, a concern echoed in studies like Villasenor (2019). Algorithmic bias occurs when the AI model, often inadvertently, favours specific demographics or perpetuates existing societal prejudices. Addressing this ethical dilemma requires continuous scrutiny of the algorithms, meticulous dataset curation, and ongoing efforts to mitigate biases. The study by Angwin et al. (2016) on biased risk assessments in the criminal justice system provides a poignant example.
• Societal Impact and Inclusivity: AI's impact on society transcends individual interactions, prompting ethical considerations on a broader scale. The concept of the digital divide, as highlighted by United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), underscores the ethical responsibility of marketers to ensure that AI-driven strategies do not inadvertently contribute to social inequalities. Ethical marketing practices should strive for inclusivity, considering the diverse needs and circumstances of different consumer segments.

In the era of AI-driven marketing, the innovative use of consumer data raises profound privacy and security concerns. The sub-theme Privacy and Security explores the importance of safeguarding consumer information, exploring the challenges and ethical considerations associated with the intersection of AI, big data, and individual privacy.

• Data Privacy and Regulatory Landscape: The marriage of AI and big data equips firms with unprecedented insights into consumer behaviour (Wilson, 2018). However, this data-driven power comes with the responsibility to navigate privacy concerns. Many government and states Consumer Privacy Acts exemplify the legal frameworks dictating data protection practices. Balancing the need for data access with regulatory compliance is a delicate task to avoid stifling innovation while respecting user privacy.
• Job Security and Ethical Data Use: As AI permeates marketing strategies, job security concerns arise among marketing professionals. The evolving nature of AI applications, such as OpenAI's ChatGPT, prompts questions about the future of marketing roles (Wong, 2023). Ethical considerations in data use become paramount — marketers must not only protect their clients' privacy but also obtain explicit consent for data utilisation (Siddiqui and Malviya, 2022). Respecting consumer preferences and ensuring ethical data practices become integral to maintaining trust.
• Privacy-Personalisation Paradox: The privacy-personalisation paradox encapsulates the intricate trade-off consumers face between privacy concerns and the allure of personalised recommendations (Aguirre et al., 2015). Understanding this paradox requires insights into individual and contextual factors influencing consumer decisions. The evolving nature of this trade-off across different product categories and changing consumer attitudes over time necessitates ongoing research to inform responsible AI-driven marketing strategies.
• Data Breaches and Unintended Consequences: The proliferation of AI applications heightens the risk of data breaches and unintended consequences (Fowler, 2019). For instance, the integration of facial identification AI into devices like the Ring doorbell raises concerns about unauthorised access and potential misuse of recorded data. Research in this sub-theme aims to illuminate potential risks and offer insights into pre-emptive measures and crisis management strategies for businesses adopting AI-driven technologies.

Sub-theme 2 highlights the intricate relationship between AI-driven marketing and privacy-security considerations. Drawing on ethical data practices and the evolving landscape of consumer preferences, this exploration highlights the need for a balanced approach. Businesses embracing AI in marketing must be vigilant custodians of consumer privacy, ensuring that innovation aligns with ethical standards and regulatory requirements. As AI solidifies its presence in marketing communications, ethical and privacy considerations take centre stage. The sub-themes of Ethical Issues and Bias, and Privacy and Security, underline the need for a nuanced approach to AI integration, emphasising ethical frameworks, unbiased algorithms, and a delicate equilibrium between data-driven insights and individual privacy.

5. Conclusion and Recommendations

The symbiotic relationship between AI and marketing communications is complex, requiring a thoughtful and balanced approach. As businesses navigate this evolving landscape, understanding the multifaceted roles of AI is essential. The tripartite model introduced by Huang and Rust (2020) offers a strategic framework for organisations to categorise AI capabilities into 'mechanical AI,' 'thinking AI,' and 'feeling AI.' Leveraging these capabilities across the marketing spectrum, from research and strategy formation to execution, can drive meaningful transformation. This study's findings place emphasis on the need for continuous exploration and adaptation in response to the evolving dynamics of AI in marketing communications. Businesses should prioritise developing robust strategies for AI integration into their marketing operations. Strategic decision-making, encompassing digital marketing initiatives, should be informed by AI-driven insights. Organisations must invest in understanding and adopting AI tools that facilitate data-driven decision-making, ensuring they stay ahead in the competitive landscape. AI's introduction has significantly impacted customer experience. To harness its potential, businesses should invest in AI technologies that facilitate personalisation and adopt automated systems to optimise customer interactions. Organisations should also prioritise ethical considerations in the development and deployment of AI technologies. Mitigating biases, ensuring transparency, and safeguarding consumer privacy are crucial. By embracing the recommended strategies and prioritising ethical considerations, businesses can position themselves to thrive in an AI-driven future. Ongoing research and industry collaboration will be crucial in shaping the responsible and effective integration of AI into the fabric of marketing communications.

---

Author Contributions: N Ramlutchman guided K Gayaparsad in writing the introduction and conclusion and recommendations sections. N Ramlutchman assisted in writing the literature, methodology and discussion of themes sections.

Funding: This research received no external funding.

Conflicts of Interest: The authors state that they have no conflicts of interest.

---

Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The views, statements, opinions, data and information presented in all publications belong exclusively to the respective Author/s and Contributor/s, and not to Sprint Investify, the journal, and/or the editorial team. Hence, the publisher and editors disclaim responsibility for any harm and/or injury to individuals or property arising from the ideas, methodologies, propositions, instructions, or products mentioned in this content.

References

1. Aguirre, E., Mahr, D., Grewal, D., de Ruyter, K., and Wetzels, M., 2015. Unraveling the Personalisation Paradox: The Effect of Information Collection and Trust-Building Strategies on Online Advertisement Effectiveness. Journal of Retailing, 91(1), pp. 34–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jretai.2014.09.005
2. Angwin, J., Larson, J., Mattu, S., and Kirchner, L., 2016. Machine bias: There's software used across the country to predict future criminals. And it's biased against blacks. ProPublica. [online] Available at: https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessments-in-criminal-sentencing (accessed 12 October 2023).
3. Balducci, B., and Marinova, D., 2018. Unstructured data in marketing. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 46(4), pp. 557–590. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11747-018-0581-x
4. Braun, V., and Clarke, V., 2006. Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), pp. 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
5. Chatterjee, S., Ghosh, S.K., Chaudhuri, R., and Nguyen, B., 2019. Are CRM systems ready for AI integration? The Bottom Line, 32(2), pp. 144–157. https://doi.org/10.1108/bl-02-2019-0069
6. Chintalapati, S., and Pandey, S.K., 2021. Artificial Intelligence in Marketing: A Systematic Literature Review. International Journal of Market Research, 64(1), pp. 38–68. https://doi.org/10.1177/14707853211018428
7. Chung, T.S., Wedel, M., and Rust, R.T., 2015. Adaptive personalisation using social networks. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science. 44(1), pp. 66–87. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11747-015-0441-x
8. Creswell, J.W., and Creswell, J.D., 2018. Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches (5^th ed.). London: Sage Publications
9. Dumitriu, D., and Popescu, M.A.M., 2020. Artificial Intelligence Solutions for Digital Marketing. Procedia Manufacturing, 46, pp. 630–636. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.promfg.2020.03.090
10. Ekström, A., 2023. The Rise of AI: How It Will Change the Future of Marketing. LinkedIn. [online] Available at: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/rise-ai-how-change-future-marketing-antti-ekstr%C3%B6m (accessed 13 September 2023).
11. Eriksson, T., Bigi, A., and Bonera, M., 2020. Think with Me, Or Think for Me? On the Future Role of Artificial Intelligence in Marketing Strategy Formulation. The TQM Journal, 32(4), pp. 795–814. https://doi.org/10.1108/tqm-12-2019-0303
12. Forrest, E., and Hoanca, B., 2015. Artificial Intelligence: Marketing’s Game Changer. In T. Tsiakis (Ed.), Trends and Innovations in Marketing Information Systems (pp. 45–64). Pennsylvania: IGI Global
13. Fowler, G., 2019. The doorbells have eyes: The privacy battles brewing over home security cameras. The Washington Post. [online] Available at: https://www.sltrib.com/news/business/2019/02/01/doorbells-have-eyes/ (accessed 3 September 2023).
14. Gans, J. S., 2016. Keep calm and manage disruption. MIT Sloan Management Review, 57(3), pp. 83-90.
15. Girdhar, R., 2023. The Impact of AI (Artificial Intelligence) on Marketing Techniques. New Zealand Herpetology, 12(3), pp. 5830-5833.
16. Haenlein, M., and Kaplan, A., 2019. A brief history of artificial intelligence: On the past, present, and future of artificial intelligence. California Management Review, 61(4), pp. 5-14.
17. Haleem, A., Javaid, M., Qadri, M., Singh, R., and Suman, R., 2022. Artificial intelligence (AI) applications for Marketing: A Literature-Based Study. International Journal of Intelligent Networks, 3(3), pp.119-132. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijin.2022.08.0
18. Huang, M. H., and Rust, R. T., 2020. A Strategic Framework for Artificial Intelligence in Marketing. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 49(1), pp. 30-50.
19. Huang, M.-H., and Rust, R. T., 2018. Artificial Intelligence in Service. Journal of Service Research, 21(2), pp. 154–173. https://doi.org/10.1177/1094670517752459
20. Karimova, G. Z., and Shirkhanbeik, A., 2019. Marketing Artificial Intelligence: Creating the AI Archetype for Evoking the Personality Trust. Academy of Marketing Studies Journal, 23(4), pp. 1–13.
21. Kelly, S. D., 2019. What computers can't create? MIT Technology Review, 122(2), pp. 68–75.
22. Khokhar, P., and Chitsimran., 2019. Evolution of Artificial Intelligence in Marketing, Comparison with Traditional Marketing. Our Heritage, 5, pp. 375–389.
23. Kose, U., Sert, S., and Kose, U., 2017. Improving Content Marketing Processes with the Approaches by Artificial Intelligence. Ecoforum, 6 (1), pp.1–8. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1704.02114
24. Krsteva, M.S.T., 2016. Artificial intelligence in marketing and advertising. International Journal of Science and Arts, 85.
25. Kumar, V., Rajan, B., Venkatesan, R., and Lecinski, J., 2019. Understanding the Role of Artificial Intelligence in Personalised Engagement Marketing. California Management Review, 61(4), pp.135–155.
26. Liao, T., 2014. Augmented or augmented reality? The Influence of Marketing on Augmented Reality Technologies. Information, Communication and Society, 18(3), pp. 310–326. https://doi.org/10.1080/1369118x.2014.989252
27. Longoni, C., Bonezzi, A., and Morewedge, C. K., 2019. Resistance to Medical Artificial Intelligence. Journal of Consumer Research, 46(4), pp. 629–650. https://doi.org/10.1093/jcr/ucz013
28. Martin, K. D., and Murphy, P. E., 2016. The Role of Data Privacy in Marketing. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 45(2), pp.135–155. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11747-016-0495-4
29. Martínez-López, F. J., and Casillas, J., 2013. Artificial Intelligence-Based Systems Applied in Industrial Marketing: An Historical Overview, Current and Future Insights. Industrial Marketing Management, 42(4), pp. 489–495. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indmarman.2013.03.001
30. Maxwell, A. L., Jeffrey, S. A., and Lévesque, M., 2011. Business Angel Early-Stage Decision Making. Journal of Business Venturing, 26(2), pp. 212–225. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusvent.2009.09.002
31. Misra, K., Schwartz, E. M., and Abernethy, J., 2019. Dynamic Online Pricing with Incomplete Information Using Multiarmed Bandit Experiments. Marketing Science, 38(2), pp. 226–252. https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2018.1129
32. Mogalakwe, M., 2006. The Use of Documentary Research Methods in Social Research. African Sociological Review, 10(1), pp. 221-230.
33. Murgai, A., 2018. Transforming Digital Marketing with Artificial Intelligence. International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management and Applied Science, 7(4), pp.259–262.
34. Nolden, C., 2023. How AI is Changing Marketing Communications. Burrelles. [online] Available at: https://burrelles.com/how-ai-is-changing-marketing-communications/ [Accessed 3 September 2023].
35. Overgoor, G., Chica, M., Rand, W. and Weishampel, A., 2019. Letting the Computers Take Over: Using AI to Solve Marketing Problems. California Management Review, 61(4), pp. 156–185. https://doi.org/10.1177/0008125619859318
36. Pascucci, F., Savelli, E. and Gistri, G., 2023. How Digital Technologies Reshape Marketing: Evidence from a Qualitative Investigation. Italian Journal of Marketing, 2023, pp. 27–58. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43039-023-00063-6
37. Rabby, F., Chimhundu, R., and Hassan, R., 2021. Artificial Intelligence in Digital Marketing Influences Consumer Behaviour: A Review and Theoretical Foundation for Future Research. Academy of Marketing Studies Journal, 25(5), pp. 1-7.
38. Raisch, S., and Krakowski, S., 2021. Artificial Intelligence and Management: The Automation-Augmentation Paradox. Academy of Management Review, 46(1), pp.192–210. https://doi.org/10.5465/2018.0072
39. Robson, C., 2016. Real World Research: A Resource for Social Scientists and Practitioner-Researchers. (4^th ed.). London: Blackwell Publishers Ltd.
40. Roetzer, P., 2017. The 5P’s of Marketing Artificial Intelligence. Marketing Artificial Intelligence Institute blog. [online] Available at: https://www.marketingaiinstitute.com/blog/the5ps-of-marketing-artificial-intelligence [Accessed 20 September 2023].
41. Siddiqui, B., and Malviya, A. K., 2022. Elucidating the Role of Artificial Intelligence in Enhancing Digital Marketing. Aweshkar Research Journal, 29(2), pp. 10–22.
42. Verma, S., Sharma, R., Deb, S., and Maitra, D., 2021. Artificial Intelligence in Marketing: Systematic Review and Future Research Direction. International Journal of Information Management Data Insights, 1(1), p. 100002. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jjimei.2020.100002
43. Villasenor, J., 2019. Artificial Intelligence and Bias: Four Key Challenges. Brookings Education. [online] Available at: https://www.brookings.edu/blog/techtank/2019/01/03/artificial-intelligence-and-bias-four-key-challenges/  [Accessed 10 October 2023].
44. Vollero, A., and Palazzo, M., 2015. Conceptualising Content Marketing: A Delphi Approach. Mercati and Competitività, (1), pp. 25–44. http://dx.doi.org/10.3280/MC2015-001003
45. Wilson, S., 2018. Big Privacy: The Data Privacy Compact for the Era of Big Data and AI. ZDNET. [online] Available at: https://www.zdnet.com/article/big-privacy-the-data-privacy-compact-for-the-era-of-big-data-and-ai [Accessed 13 September 2023].
46. Wong, J., 2023. Artificial Intelligence is Revolutionising Marketing. Here's What the Transformation Means for the Industry. Entrepreneur. [online] Available at:  https://www.entrepreneur.com/science-technology/why-artificial-intelligence-is-revolutionizing-marketing/446087 [Accessed 13 September 2023].
47. Wright, C., Allnutt, J., Campbell, R., Evans, M., Forman, R., Gibson, J., Jolly, S., Kerlin, L., Lechelt, S., Phillipson, G., and Shotton, M., 2020. AI in Production: Video Analysis and Machine Learning for Expanded Live Events Coverage. SMPTE Motion Imaging Journal, 129(2), pp. 36–45. https://doi.org/10.5594/JMI.2020.2967204
48. Yau, K.-L.A.; Saad, N.M.; Chong, Y.-W., 2021. Artificial Intelligence Marketing (AIM) for Enhancing Customer Relationships. Applied Sciences, (11)18, pp. 8562. https://doi.org/10.3390/app11188562

Article Rights and License

Corresponding Author